The United Arab Emirates ratcheted up tension with oil allies in OPEC+, with officials privately questioning the benefits of being in the producers’ alliance and even considering whether to leave it.
The UAE has not said publicly it’s debating its membership, let alone planning to exit. And officials briefed the media under condition they would not be named, allowing room for maneuver if they later want to distance themselves from the comments.
The move is unusual because the UAE — the biggest producer in OPEC after Saudi Arabia and Iraq — has long avoided public clashes, preferring to solve disputes quietly behind closed doors. It’s unclear whether the warning is designed to force a negotiation over output levels with OPEC+’s leaders Saudi Arabia and Russia, or if it represents a genuine policy debate. Any decision to leave OPEC would need the approval of Mohammed bin Zayed, the UAE’s de factor ruler and Abu Dhabi’s crown prince.
Tension between Riyadh and Abu Dhabi has grown since late summer, when the UAE breached its OPEC+ quota and got a stern warning from its neighbor. Emirati policy makers seem increasingly frustrated by what they see as an unfair allocation of production caps and as the UAE economy reels from shriveling oil revenue and the coronavirus pandemic.
It comes at a delicate moment for OPEC+, which propped up oil prices with historic agreement to cut supply and offset the impact of the pandemic on demand. Any signs of cracks in the alliance — let alone dissent from a producer as big as the UAE — would undermine an already fragile market.
Brent crude fell 0.1% to $44.28 a barrel as of 8:35 a.m. in London. The benchmark has more than doubled since OPEC+ struck its deal in April, but is still down 33% this year.
The group needs to decide in the next two weeks whether to go ahead with a January production increase as set out in the agreement, or delay it. So far, Riyadh and Moscow have signaled they are prepared to delay the hike as the virus continues to sap demand for energy.
Earlier, Energy Intelligence reported the UAE was weighing up the pros and cons of OPEC membership. No one was available to comment at the oil ministry.
This week, a panel of OPEC+ ministers told the group — an alliance between the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries and others such as Russia — to be vigilant about the market despite a rally in oil prices. “All participating countries need to be vigilant, proactive and be prepared to act, when necessary, to the requirements of the market,” the panel said in a statement.
UAE Energy Minister Suhail Al-Mazrouei sounded more circumspect and took a line unusually distant from that of Saudi Arabia. He said everyone must first be convinced of the need to delay the production increase.
Oil rose to its highest since early September on Wednesday on further signs of stronger demand in China, India and other Asian nations, and with pharmaceutical companies making progress on Covid-19 vaccines.